Showing posts with label Malam Bacai Sanha. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Malam Bacai Sanha. Show all posts

Friday, April 9, 2010

Guinea-Bissau Needs Military, Other Reforms

Guinea-Bissau is experiencing times of political and military instability once again, a situation that reflects the fragility of the institutions of the "Republic." Contrary to what some might think, the government is not the holder of "real power" any more than the president and anyone who thinks otherwise is laboring under a misapprehension.

A total of 36 years after independence and 19 after the implantation of the democratic regime the fact is that there continue to be obstacles to the affirmation of the State in Guinea-Bissau and consequently the consolidation of democratic structures.

Existing Political and Social Pluralism
In spite of the existing political and social pluralism reflected in the existence of more than 20 political parties and civilian organizations, the hideous and barbaric assassinations of public figures, especially in the more recent past, in addition to constant threats to opposing voices that have succeeded in reducing the room for maneuver of the opposition, civilian society, and citizens at large. There has also been a certain decrease in freedoms of expression such as expressing opposition and staging demonstrations all of which reflects a step back in terms of democratic gains.

Guinea-Bissau had lived in apparent calm since December 2009 because of the government's incapacity and the failure of the UN mediation peacefully to settle the issue of former Navy Chief Rear Admiral Jose Americo Bubo Na Tchuto who had been a refugee in the UN premises in Bissau since then. It stood to reason that it was a situation the consequences of which simply could not be ignored.

Problem of Military Class
Given the contours of that particular problem was anyone naïf enough to suppose that there would be a peaceful outcome to it? The political power in Guinea-Bissau has been postponing rather than settling conflicts and so everything remains open and from "incident to incident" one sees more and more disorder, people being detained or killed, and no punishment at all for the culprits.

It has become clear that the country's power structures are impotent to settle the problem of the military class. After all, who is the chief of General Staff of the Guinea-Bissau Armed Forces? Who will be the new chief of General Staff of the Guinea-Bissau Armed Forces to be appointed by President of the Republic Malam Bacai Sanha?

The military situation in Guinea-Bissau is quite complex and it demands an answer that will be founded not just on the implementation of the Constitution and of the Law on National Defense but also on the sensitivities and perceptions at work within the Armed Forces. A failure to address the military issue could see it spread to society with predictably grave consequences.
What is more, it has become clear that there are factions within the Armed Forces even though it is equally clear that reform in the Defense and Security Sector is imperative and must not stalled any more but it should happen in tandem with reform in the Public Service and Justice sectors.

In-Depth Reform Needed
There is the need for in-depth reform in State institutions. The current situation of anarchy has been sustained by the inertia of the justice sector that has made little or no contribution to a much desired climate of peace and social stability.

It is far from being a simple matter of demanding justice to deal with the "evils" that have beset the country, including the participation of some and the complicity of others that are not known yet. What is at stake is the very defense of the country's interests and if the political powers that be are not able to manage this situation legally and reasonably then a new conflict is only being swept under the carpet but it is bound to rear its head at a later point.

The exercise of power is to have the authority and to ensure that the law is complied with and the State is the implementation of the law, not the use of force.

Wednesday, April 7, 2010

Post-Coup Developments in Guinea-Bissau

After the military coup in Guinea-Bissau on 1 April, the capital -- Bissau -- has been waking up in apparent calm only slightly disturbed by the comings and goings of international envoys as they engage in talks with the President of the Republic and the prime minister. President Malam Bacai Sanha has shown that he is a consummate strategist in terms of internal diplomacy.
After a silence that went on for as long as the military coup he elected to not rock either side's boat and gave the assurance that "all is well in the kingdom.

Threat To Execute Prime Minister
As for Prime Minister Carlos Gomes Junior he also confirmed rather laconically that all was well but was promptly abducted by forces loyal to Guinea-Bissau Armed Forces Deputy Chief of Staff General Antonio Indjai who made apologies for his verbal inadequacies after publicly threatening to execute the prime minister.

Rear Admiral Bubo Na Tchuto (former Navy chief who fled to the Gambia and had lately been a refugee in the UN office premises in Bissau) decided to take it a step further when he called for the prime minister to go on trial. Let it be noted, however, that the possibility that the head of government might be removed has not been ruled out and if it were to happen it would permit the creation of a presidential type of government.

The euphoria of the military coup over, the citizens of Guinea-Bissau resumed their normal lives on Friday [2 April]. The markets reopened, the street vendors went back to their routine, and shops resumed business as has happened at other Easter holidays over the years. However, this apparent calm has not hidden the fact that the ruling African Party for the Independence of Guinea and Cape Verde, PAIGC is currently beset by an internal storm where there are two opposing fields steadily but clearly taking up positions.

The two sides have only one point on which they agree, namely that the situation in the country must be played down for external consumption. They have, however, failed to convince the international community and in particular the representatives of CPLP (Community of Portuguese-speaking Countries), the United Nations, the African Union (AU), and the Economic Community of West African States, Ecowas.

Declaration of Cold War
A Cold War already has been declared and made more definite by the followers of President Malam Bacai Sanha and of Cadogo (nickname given to Prime Minister Carlos Gomes Junior) but there continue to be efforts to preserve a peaceful coexistence within the ruling party.

Jose Zamora Induta, Guinea-Bissau Armed Forces Chief of Staff General and Colonel Samba Djalo, head of the General Staff Military Information and Security Department, are still in detention. They were initially behind bars in the Bissau air base and then were transferred to the army barracks in Mansoa. The military rebels have accused the former of misusing his powers and the latter is believed to have been responsible for the posting on the Internet of a document that provide an account of "divisions within the PAIGC implicating in them some of the country’s most senior officials."

The 'Dictatorship of Consensus' (Ditadura do Consenso)' blog has had access to the rather controversial document and published it in full. The document was presumably signed by Samba Djalo and dated 10 November 2009.

The document entitled 'Internal Threats and Risks of Instability' was classified 'secret' by its author and it disclosed that there were tiffs between Cadogo and then President Joao Bernardo 'Nino' Vieira during the former's first tour of duty. It also warned that within the ruling party "one can detect the existence of various factions making for constant convulsions within the party" and it disclosed the names of militants that in November 2009 were regarded by Samba Djalo as very close to PAIGC president: Marciano S. Barbeiro, Daniel Gomes, Roberto Cacheu, Conduto de Pina, Soares Sambu, and Isabel Buscardine.

Instability-Related Risks
According to the then chief of DINFOSEMIL (Guinea-Bissau Armed Forces Military Information and Security Division) those same elements turned up at the party congress in the city of Gabu as supporters of Martinho Imdafa Cabi, one of the candidates in the party’s leadership," adding that "the way things have been evolving there are internal instability-related risks because all those members are sure to be part of the presidential team headed by President of the Republic Malam Bacai Sanha.

Samba Djalo stressed that "even though they all belong in the same party with the prime minister the fact is that there is a lack of trust that translates into internal contradictions in the party's midst and which could lead to a poisoning of the relationship between the two most senior officials in the country."

In the document, the former DINFOSEMIL chief noted that "this situation already has attracted comments that our services are well aware of thanks to our aerials and they have become aware of the fact that there are PAIGC militants that support the idea of holding a special congress with a view to pushing Prime Minister Carlos Gomes Junior out of the PAIGC leadership and by extension out of the post of prime minister."